Resources to help you integrate digital tools into your mental health practice
This page collects and shares resources that can support the integration of digital mental health tools into the interaction between client and provider. The tools have a wide range of objectives, formats and audiences. The primary audience for this page is health care providers working in mental health in Canada who are looking for support in integrating digital health tools into their clinical practice.
Last update: March 2021
Health care providers and other providers in mental health care, including psychiatrists, psychologists, counsellors, psychotherapists, nurses, primary care physicians, social workers, occupational therapists and peer support workers
Health care providers and other providers in mental health care, including psychiatrists, psychologists, counsellors, psychotherapists, nurses, primary care physicians, social workers, occupational therapists and peer support workers
Administrators wishing to increase the uptake of digital mental health tools, such as program planners, digital health implementation specialists, information management / information technology specialists and process improvement specialists.
In addition, clients and caregivers are the audience for several of the resources on this page. We invite clients and caregivers to use the page to identify resources that might be helpful to them. The primary audience for this page will vary between organizations, depending on contextual factors such as size, policies and existing infrastructure. We encourage you to consult within your organization before implementing a resource listed here.
These types of tools remain relatively new. Much of the focus to date has been in helping users choose and integrate apps and in implementing digital mental health programs through comprehensive guides. The COVID-19 pandemic of 2020 resulted in a sharp increase in the use of telemedicine tools. However, any gaps remain.
This project is not:
Information on how to use a given resource is often provided in the resource itself. For many resources, it is self-evident. In the summary of each resource, we provide some basic information on how to use it.
Information on how to use a given resource is often provided in the resource itself. For many resources, it is self-evident. In the summary of each resource, we provide some basic information on how to use it.
When thinking about how you might use a resource in your clinical practice, consider the discussion in the next section of barriers and facilitating factors that influence the uptake of digital mental health tools.
Administrator: A person working in the mental health care sector who performs business operations roles that support the clinical care functions of an organization.
Administrator: A person working in the mental health care sector who performs business operations roles that support the clinical care functions of an organization.
App assessment resource: A resource that provides a generic model or framework that the user follows to evaluate an app of their choice; the resource does not provide an assessment of an app but rather guidance on how to assess an app.
App rating resource: A resource that provides summaries and expert ratings of different apps; the resource offers an expert assessment of different apps.
App selection tool: An interactive tool that provides access to a collection of apps. Apps are presented based on a series of questions or filters based on specific characteristics of the app, such as audience or type of therapy.
Caregiver: An informal care provider, such as a family member, friend or other social support, whom a client calls upon for help, care and support.
Client: A person who accesses mental health services or seeks mental health care.
Health care provider: A trained health professional or allied health worker who provides care and services to people looking for mental health care.
Implementation resource: A resource that provides information and guidance on how to establish and operate a program or practice that incorporates a digital mental health tool; these resources often target larger projects that involve changes to workflow and care practices.
Resource: A website, document, poster, or other material that can help to integrate different digital mental health tools into practice; for example, a website that reviews and rates apps can help identify the right tool for a client.
Resource collection: A collection of resources curated to focus on a particular topic.
Tool: An app, website, device or other digital mental health technology that is to be used by the client or the provider, together or separately; for example, a tool could be a cognitive behavioural therapy app.
App libraries
App Library (Health Navigator New Zealand https://www.healthnavigator.org.nz/apps/
App libraries
App Library (Health Navigator New Zealand https://www.healthnavigator.org.nz/apps/
Apps Library (National Health Service, United Kingdom https://www.nhs.uk/apps-library/
Reviewed Mental Health Apps (Anxiety and Depression Association of America) https://adaa.org/finding-help/mobile-apps
App assessment frameworks
Guiding Principles for Physicians Recommending Mobile Health Applications (Canadian Medical Association) https://policybase.cma.ca/en/permalink/policy11521
Mobile Application Rating Scale (MARS) App Classification (Ministry of Health, New Zealand) https://www.health.govt.nz/system/files/documents/pages/guidance-evaluating-developing-health-app-oct17-v2.pdf
Implementation guides
Digital Health Implementation Playbook (American Medical Association) https://www.ama-assn.org/amaone/ama-digital-health-implementation-playbook
e-Mental health guide and strategic planning worksheet (ACCESS Open Minds) https://accessopenminds.ca/wp-content/uploads/dlm_uploads/2018/08/ACCESS-Open-Minds-eMental-Health-Guide-EN-vers20180723.pdf
Best Practice Guideline: Adopting eHealth Solutions: Implementation Strategies (Registered Nurses Association of Ontario) https://rnao.ca/sites/rnao-ca/files/bpg/Digital_Health_Guideline.pdf
Telemental health
Center for Care Innovations Resource Center (USA) https://www.careinnovations.org/resources/
Telepsychiatry toolkit (American Psychiatric Association) https://www.psychiatry.org/psychiatrists/practice/telepsychiatry/toolkit
Guidance on telemental health for mental health services and practitioners (eMEN, Ireland) https://www.mentalhealthreform.ie/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/eMEN-rapid-briefing-paper_-COVID-19_final-12.pdf
Therapy decision guides
Stepped Care Guide: A promising model to improve access to mental health care on campus (Memorial University, St. John’s, Newfoundland) https://campusmentalhealth.ca/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Stepped-Care-Guide-V10.pdf
Therapy option guide (Anxiety and Depression Association of America) https://adaa.org/sites/default/files/final-therapygu_23840851_3ad732e6e2a37020f3ac49fcaf48f6305f631dcf_0.jpeg
Comprehensive web resources
E-Mental Health in Practice (Black Dog Institute, Australia) https://www.blackdoginstitute.org.au/education-training/health-professionals/emental-health-in-practice
Improving Patient-Centred Technology Use (iPaCT) Education and Evaluation Toolkit (University of Chicago) https://www.mededportal.org/publication/9953/
(Based on a literature search conducted in late 2019.)
Advances in technology continue to revolutionize the health care system and influence the practice of health care professionals.
(Based on a literature search conducted in late 2019.)
Advances in technology continue to revolutionize the health care system and influence the practice of health care professionals.
The COVID-19 world pandemic of 2020 provided additional impetus to use digital mental health tools, both to provide care while adhering to public health prevention guidelines and to support people manage the stress of the pandemic. Introducing digital tools and technology into the mental health care system has the potential to shorten wait times, increase access in rural and remote communities, and provide cost-effective access to care.(1) Research has demonstrated that many mental health care providers are aware of and ready to utilize these opportunities.
Nonetheless, several factors specific to mental health care need to be considered when implementing digital tools. One overarching consideration to keep in mind is that no single tool will work for everyone.(1) Other factors to consider are described below.
Potential uses
Enthusiasm for the use of digital tools is high among mental health care providers: in one survey, 98% of respondents said they were ready to use technology to support their clients.(2) Providers see the potential for digital health tools to increase access to mental health care and support for their clients.
There are many potential ways in which digital health tools may be used in mental health care. Here are a few examples:
Ethical, legal, privacy and confidentiality considerations
It is important to help clients to understand the ethical, legal, privacy and confidentiality considerations of digital tools. Areas to consider include:
Emergency and crisis situations
Face-to-face contact
Research shows that mental health care providers are beginning to incorporate digital health tools in providing ongoing face-to-face services.(6) They express strong interest in the ability of these tools to extend therapy beyond each individual session.(4) However, there are also concerns about this trend:
Reliability of digital tools and technologies
Providers may need to discuss the reliability of digital tools and technologies with clients. This may include discussing the challenges in choosing the most appropriate tool, especially for clients with complex and comorbid clinical presentations, or presentations that change over time.(2,7,11,12) It is possible that unintended consequences may arise from using digital mental health tools that lack empirical support.(7)
Not all providers may be open to using technology-based interventions, leading to additional skepticism about reliability.(11)
Logistical factors
Three logistical factors to consider are training, time, and the interaction between new tools and existing policy and procedures:
Additional considerations
References
Project team
Gillian Strudwick, RN, PhD, CAMH, Toronto
Project team
Gillian Strudwick, RN, PhD, CAMH, Toronto
David McLay, PhD, CAMH, Toronto
Leanne M. Currie, RN, PhD, University of British Columbia, Vancouver
Nicole Thomson, OT Reg. (Ont.), PhD, CAMH, Toronto
Eric Maillet, RN, PhD, University of Sherbrooke, Longueil
Janis Campbell, MEd, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John’s
Alanna Miller, BSc, McGill University, Montreal
Hwayeon Danielle Shin, BScN, RN, Dalhousie University, Halifax
Vanessa Strong, MSc, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John’s
Project genesis
In Canada, numerous digital health tools have been developed specifically for people with mental illness, which has the potential to lead to significant benefits. However, engagement of providers and clients with these tools is often inconsistent, and in many cases poor. Uptake needs to be improved for benefits to be realized. Some resources to support the uptake of these digital tools have been developed, but these resources are not well known and have not been consolidated into a single document. Thus, a project that aims to consolidate these resources was identified as a need. The project was completed in April 2020. An update to the resource list was completed in early 2021.
Version 1 of the resource collection: https://tinyurl.com/digitalMH
Guiding principles
Discussions by the project team, along with valuable feedback from stakeholders from across Canada—including those with lived experience of mental illness—led to the definition of guiding principles for the project. These principles include the following:
Goals and objective
The goals of this project are to:
Project design
The project was developed using methods recommended by the United States Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) on toolkit creation.(16)
The project design including environmental scan (participants list below), grey literature search methodology (lists of organizations included below), and workshop are published in:
Strudwick G, McLay D, Lo B, Shin HD, Currie L, Thomson N, Maillet E, Strong V, Miller A, Shen N, Campbell J. Development of a Resource Guide to Support the Engagement of Mental Health Providers and Patients with Digital Health Tools: A Multi-method Study
JMIR Preprints. 14/11/2020:25773
DOI: 10.2196/preprints.25773
URL: https://preprints.jmir.org/preprint/25773
Environmental scan participants
Organizations included in original grey literature scan
Mental health organizations
Medical organizations or hospitals
Client organizations or websites
Governmental organizations
Other
The Digital Mental Health website (the “Site") is made available though a collaboration between the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (“CAMH”) and Canada Health Infoway, (together "we", "us").
The Digital Mental Health website (the “Site") is made available though a collaboration between the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (“CAMH”) and Canada Health Infoway, (together "we", "us").
General viewing of the Site is subject to acceptance of the following terms of use ("Terms of Use"). Please read these Terms of Use carefully. By continuing to use the Site you ("you", with references to "your" as applicable) agree that you have accepted these Terms of Use. Users who access the Site are referred to as “users” throughout these Terms of Use.
We provide this Site to share resources that can support the integration of digital mental health tools into the interaction between a client and provider. The primary audience for this page is health care providers working in mental health in Canada who are looking for support in integrating digital health tools into their clinical practice however certain resources may be useful for clients and caregivers and the general public as well. To that end, we provide information to the public and professionals that is accessible, current at the time of posting and reliable, however, we make no representations or warranties regarding the accuracy, quality, completeness, timeliness, appropriateness or sustainability of the Content (as defined below). We assume no obligation to update the Content or advise on further developments concerning the topics mentioned in the Content. You acknowledge that the Site, the Content, and each website service are provided on an "AS IS" basis; and that any use of or reliance on this Site or any Content shall be at your sole risk.
We reserve the right in its sole discretion to add, remove, modify or otherwise change the Terms of Use at any time. Your continued use of the Site following the posting of any such changes will mean you accept the changes. If any change to the Terms is unacceptable to you, you should cease using the Site. In addition, we reserve the right, in our sole discretion, to add, remove or modify any Content on this Site. We also reserve the right, in our sole discretion, to correct any errors or omissions to any part of the Site but have no duty to do so, and the Terms shall apply to any such changed version of the Site. ** **
Ownership and Permitted Use
CAMH owns all of the copyright in this Site, including its postings, messages, text, graphics, images, and other material contained on the Site (the "Content") unless otherwise specifically noted. Your use of the Site does not transfer to you any ownership or other rights in the Site or its Content. You may not copy, publish, reproduce, modify, upload, post, transmit or distribute any of the Content in any manner or form without the prior consent of an authorized representative of CAMH, except for a brief quotation (not to exceed 200 word) in a review or professional work. Certain words, phrases, names, designs or logos used on the Site may constitute trademarks, service marks or trade names of CAMH, Canada Health Infoway or other entities. No rights are granted to Users of this Site in or to such trademarks, service marks or trade names.
Not Medical Advice
The Contents of the Site are for informational purposes only. The Content is not intended to be a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. You should always seek the immediate or timely advice of your physician or other qualified health care provider with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition. You should never disregard professional medical advice or delay in seeking it because of something you have read or seen on the Website, including the Content as described above.
Not Emergency or Crisis Care
The Website is not for emergency or crisis help. If you require emergency help, contact your local emergency services: in Ontario, you can call 911 or go to your local hospital emergency room.
Privacy Policy
The following information addresses privacy as it relates to users of the Site. We are committed to maintaining the privacy of all individuals who use the Site. We value your trust and understand that this requires that we be transparent and accountable about how we handle the information you choose to share with us. We do not trade, rent or sell the information of our Site users.
No personal information about you is collected from use of this Site.
IP Addresses
The web servers we use automatically collect information including but not limited the Internet Protocol (IP) address of the computers that access our Site, browser type and the pages viewed on the Site. An IP address is a number that is assigned to your computer when you access the Internet. It is not truly personally identifiable information because many different individuals can access the Internet via the same computer. We use this information in aggregate form to understand how our site used and how we can better serve visitors.
Cookies and Google Analytics
Similar to many websites, the Site uses digital cookies (small pieces of information that are stored on hard drives of your computer, which allows us to “remember” information about your preferences and allows you to move within areas of our site quickly and easily) to gather trend data concerning traffic on the Site for statistical analysis. We also anonymously capture information about how users interact with our site and what pages they visit. This information is used for auditing, tracking and targeted marketing purposes and to improve the Content of the Site. The data we collect is used both collectively and individually for website research to create a better experience for the users of this site. This information may be linked to you or your internet provider address. You can choose to accept or decline cookies. Most web browsers automatically accept cookies, but you can usually modify your browser setting to decline cookies if you prefer. This may prevent you from taking full advantage of the Site. This Site uses Google Analytics, a web analytics service provided by Google Inc. (“Google”). Google Analytics uses cookies to assist CAMH to analyze how visitors use the Site and to analyze the information generated by the cookies (which includes your IP address). This information is transmitted to and stored by Google. Google uses the information for the purposes of compiling reports on Site activity for CAMH, evaluating your use of the Site and providing other services to CAMH related to internet usage and website activity. By using this Site you agree to the use of Google Analytics. For more information on Google’s privacy policy, please visit their website: http://www.google.com/analytics/learn/privacy.html
Links
This Site primarily contains links to other websites or tools that are not under the ownership or operation of CAMH or Canada Health Infoway. The views expressed in the Site do not necessarily reflect the policies or opinions of authors, collaborators or funders. We do not control, recommend or endorse and are not responsible for these sites or their content, products, services or privacy policies. If you use these sites, you do so at your own risk. Downloading material from certain sites may risk infringing intellectual property rights or introducing viruses into your computer system. You should take notice when you leave this Site and read the privacy policies and terms of these other sites. ** **
Agreement
By accepting these Terms of Use, You agree to assume liability for Your actions on the Site; You will indemnify CAMH and Canada Health Infoway for any and all claims, demands or actions and losses or damages relating to and/or arising from the operation of the Site or your use of the Site. In your use of the Site, you will abide by as all applicable laws (including provincial and federal laws of Canada); You will limit our liability by agreeing that we will not be responsible for any specific level of service, but, rather will provide service on an "as is, where is" basis; and you acknowledge that we may suspend provision of the Site without prior notice. This is a Canadian website and its content is intended for Canadian residents only. The laws of the Province of Ontario shall govern this agreement and any dispute or claim based on your use of the Site or the Information and Content. You agree that any action or proceeding related to this agreement or your use of the Site shall only be brought by you in the courts of the Province of Ontario.
If you choose not to accept these Terms of Use, you may close this window now and leave the Site.
Digital Mental Health Lab / Dr. Gillian Strudwick
Canada Health Infoway
© 2020, 2021, Centre for Addiction and Mental Health
Project commissioned by Canada Health Infoway.
This project is a collaboration between the Centre for Addiction and Mental Health (CAMH) and Canada Health Infoway, in consultation with many stakeholders from across Canada.
Thank you!